Billy Joel: The reluctant rock star who redefined pop authenticity

by Dave Anthony

Host, Garage to Stadiums podcast

• Download our official Billy Joel playlist on Apple or Spotify

• Follow GTS on Apple or Spotify podcasts

• Follow GTS on Instagram, X and on LinkedIn 

• Sign up for the Garage to Stadiums e-newsletter to get more bonus content

• Access this episode's transcript

Billy Joel occupies a singular space in the music industry—neither quite a rock star nor a pop idol, but a storytelling craftsman whose authenticity, range, and defiance of musical trends have made him a lasting cultural figure. Over the span of five decades, Joel has become synonymous with piano-driven songwriting and narrative-rich lyrics, yet his true uniqueness lies in how he carved a path counter to the expectations of the music industry, consistently prioritizing substance over spectacle.

On our Joel episode, we were joined by guest Fred Schruers author of Billy Joel: The Definitive Biography. Fred was also a former Rolling Stone feature writer. He interviewed countless members in Billy's circles and created a revealing portrait of an artist who has a different approach than most rock stars.

Beyond genre labels

Unlike most contemporaries in the rock and pop scenes of the 1970s and '80s, Joel never leaned on image or genre allegiance. He didn’t ride the coattails of psychedelia, disco, or hair metal. In fact, he often avoided aligning with any movement. Instead, he moved fluidly between styles—doo-wop, jazz, classical, rockabilly, and even Soviet protest balladry—anchored not in fashion but in the emotional architecture of his lyrics. Songs like “Piano Man,” “Scenes from an Italian Restaurant,” and “Allentown” showcase this diversity. Each is a vignette, a character study, a moment in working-class American life—and each uniquely Joel.

A songwriter first

One remarkable quality that separates Billy Joel from his peers is his literary approach to songwriting. A self-taught student of classical music and literature, Joel crafted lyrics with a novelist’s precision. He often turned unglamorous subjects—blue-collar disillusionment, suburban malaise, or post-war American anxiety—into compelling anthems. His 1982 album The Nylon Curtain, for instance, was less a commercial bid and more a concept album dissecting American unrest. It included references to the Vietnam War, labor strife, and middle-class despair—a thematic risk almost unheard of in early '80s

pop.

Walking away on his own terms

Perhaps more astonishing is Joel’s decision to walk away from making pop music altogether. After his 1993 album River of Dreams, he made a conscious choice to stop releasing pop records, citing a lack of personal inspiration. In an industry that rewards perpetual output and reinvention, this was nothing short of revolutionary. Instead, he turned to composing classical pieces and performing live—a move that underscored his integrity and lifelong resistance to creative compromise.

A star without a spotlight

Billy Joel also defies the norms of celebrity. Despite being one of the best-selling artists of all time—with over 150 million records sold—he remains a remarkably private figure who has resisted the celebrity machine.

He has no Twitter account, rarely gives interviews, and yet sells out Madison Square Garden month after month as part of a residency that’s become the longest-running of its kind in music history. His staying power has nothing to do with image and everything to do with intergenerational resonance. A teenager in 2025 can feel just as connected to “Vienna” as a 40-something did in 1985.

A deep sense of place

Another facet of Joel’s uniqueness is his deep connection to place. Long Island isn’t just where he’s from—it’s embedded in his music. He gave voice to regional America in a way few global stars do, immortalizing the ordinary struggles of ordinary people in a way that transcended regional borders. His lyrics are rich with diner booths, factory floors, Catholic guilt, and suburban yearning. In a globalized industry, Joel remained fiercely local—and in doing so, became universal.

A legacy built on truth

Billy Joel didn’t just write songs—he chronicled American life. He was never the loudest, the most fashionable, or the most prolific. But in choosing authenticity over allure and storytelling over sales, he left behind something far more enduring: a legacy of timeless songs that still sound like truth.

© 2025 Garage To Stadiums Podcast