Stevie Nicks: The Underrated Rock Visionary
- Dave Anthony
- 3 days ago
- 4 min read
Updated: 2 days ago
by Dave Anthony, Host
Garage to Stadiums Music History podcast
Download our curated Stevie Nicks playlist on Apple or Spotify
Follow GTS on Instagram, X and on LinkedIn
Access this episode's transcript
Stevie Nicks is one of the most recognizable figures in rock—her
voice, her silhouette, her mystique. Yet for all her fame and influence, she remains curiously underrated in the annals of rock history. She’s often celebrated as an icon or muse, but seldom given full credit as a groundbreaking rock performer. Look closely at her artistry, achievements, and impact, and it becomes clear that Stevie Nicks is not just a star—she is one of the most vital and enduring figures in rock. Zoë Howe, author of Vision Dreams & Rumours: A Portrait of Stevie Nicks (available in book and audio) joined me to discuss Stevie's career and the reasons why she has been able to sustain a special place of importance for young and old fans alike.
Her musicianship Is vastly undervalued
Zoë our guest reminded us that Stevie was sometimes dismissed because she was not a "professional musician". However, Stevie did play guitar and piano and was a driving force of the band's creativity. In fact, Zoë went deep into the history of Stevie's sacrifice on behalf of her guitarist boyfriend Lindsey Buckingham. Her cleaning houses, waitressing and performing other odd jobs allowed LIndsey to stay at home practicing and becoming the guitar virtuoso that he would soon become. So while critics have long highlighted Buckingham’s technical virtuosity or Christine McVie’s musicianship, they often overlook Nicks’s own artistic contributions. But when Nicks joined Fleetwood Mac in 1975, she completely reshaped the band’s sonic identity.
Songs like “Rhiannon,” “Landslide,” and “Dreams” didn’t simply succeed—they transformed Fleetwood Mac from seasoned blues outfit to one of the most emotionally charged, mythic, and commercially potent rock bands of the era. Her live performances of “Rhiannon,” often described as “a witchy exorcism,” created a new template for theatrical rock performance. See the adjacent Midnight Special YouTube clip for evidence of her channelling performance.
A narrative poet disguised as a rock star
Nicks has long been pigeonholed as mystical, ethereal, or impressionistic, but this dismisses the depth of her songwriting. Her lyrics blend autobiography and myth with an emotional candor that places her closer to confessional poets like Anne Sexton than to typical rock lyricists. Songs such as “Sara,” “Silver Springs,” “Gypsy,” and “Storms” are not vague mood pieces—they are intricate emotional narratives. Her ability to turn internal chaos into sweeping, cinematic stories is a rare gift in rock, and one that has not been fully appreciated by critics who misread her poetic intensity as abstraction.
A victim of gender bias in rock canon
The story of rock history has long privileged male performers who exhibit aggression, virtuosity, or rebellion in conventional terms. Nicks embodied rebellion in a more complex way. She did not rely on technical flash; instead
, she asserted power through vulnerability, through emotional storytelling, and through a stage persona that was both mystical and unflinchingly honest.
Her visual aesthetic—shawls, chiffon, platform boots, moonlit symbolism—was once dismissed as “feminine theatrics.” Today, it is widely recognized as a groundbreaking form of identity-driven performance art. Before artists like Tori Amos, Björk, Florence Welch, Lana Del Rey, or Taylor Swift crafted mythic personal worlds, Nicks laid the blueprint. Even today, many young artists like Swift and Harry Styles have openly worshipped Stevie and performed alongside her. Further, many bands have used Fleetwood Mac's Rumours album as their own blueprint. Styles even joined her onstage at her Rock & Roll Hall of Fame induction to perform the Tom Petty vocal part of their hit "Stop Draggin' My Heart Around" as shown in the YouTube clip below.
Her voice defies conventional expectations
Stevie Nicks doesn’t possess a traditional powerhouse range; what she does possess is one of the most
distinctive vocal signatures in rock history. Her rasp, texture, and phrasing are instantly recognizable and deeply evocative. What makes her voice underrated is that critics once judged her for what she wasn’t, rather than for what she was. She isn’t Ann Wilson or Janis Joplin. Instead, she is a vocalist who can turn a lyric into a living emotional experience. Onstage, she reshapes songs to fit the emotional truth of the moment—stretching syllables, deepening resonance, and transforming her performances into cathartic rituals.
A solo career that should be considered legendary
Nicks’s solo career remains one of the most successful of any artist who came from a major band, yet it’s often treated as a footnote rather than a breakthrough. Her run of solo albums—Bella Donna, The Wild Heart, Rock a Little, and The Other Side of the Mirror—influenced the sound of female-fronted pop-rock for decades.
“Edge of Seventeen” is a rock anthem built on one of the most iconic riffs of all time.“Stand Back” anticipates the synth-forward sound of the late ’80s and early ’90s.“Rooms on Fire” showcases her ability to blend autobiographical reflection with sweeping emotional production. These works cement her not just as a band member, but as a creative force in her own right.
Her cultural longevity is unmatched
Few rock performers have remained culturally relevant across five decades without compromising their identity. Nicks continues to influence fashion, songwriting, and the visual language of performance. Younger artists cite her as a beacon of emotional storytelling, feminine strength, and artistic authenticity.
Her ability to confront personal demons openly—from addiction to heartbreak—has made her a symbol of resilience and survival. Her stories resonate because she never pretended to be untouchable; instead, she embraced imperfection as part of her art.
Why she’s truly underrated
Stevie Nicks is underrated not because her fame is lacking, but because her artistry is still misunderstood. Rock history often exalts technical precision and masculine bravado. Nicks offered something else: emotional alchemy, poetic vulnerability, and mythic self-invention.She made rock more expansive, more imaginative, more emotionally honest.
Her contributions—musical, visual, lyrical, cultural—are foundational to the genre. The fact that she is only now receiving long-overdue recognition says more about rock’s historical blind spots than about her achievements.
Stevie Nicks is not merely an icon—she is one of rock’s most consequential performers. History is still catching up to her, but when the story of rock is fully told, her place near the top will be undeniable.
© 2025 Garage To Stadiums Podcast
