Ranked as one of the Top 3% of podcasts globally
Source: Listen Notes
Joni Mitchell was artist with a voice and a guitar sound unlike anyone else. She had the poet's words and had a painter's eye. Joni Mitchell brought all four of these elements together to change the possibilities of popular music.
From her famous song Both Sides Now to the emotional depths of her critically acclaimed album Blue, she pioneered a place for women in songwriting and performing, inspired generations, won Grammys, and pushed beyond folk and pop into other adventurous forms of music. You'll also experience the life of upheaval behind that extraordinary music: a childhood disease, a daughter placed for adoption, a further devastating health challenge.

Transcript: The Story of Joni Mitchell
Garage to Stadiums Music History Podcast
Host, Dave Anthony
Guest: Alison Rapp, Host of The Big Yellow Podcast
[00:00:00] Dave Anthony: Hi there. I'm Dave Anthony, and this is the Garage to Stadiums Music History Podcast. On each episode, we tell you the story of how one of our music legends rose from obscurity to fame, and play some of the songs that marked that journey Firstly, we want to thank you, our loyal and growing audience. We've just received word that our podcast, Garage to Stadiums, is now in the top 3% of podcasts globally.
[00:00:26] Dave Anthony: So thank you for passing it on, leaving reviews, and helping to grow the nation of music history fans. Welcome to Garage to Stadiums. Today's episode is the story of Joni Mitchell. Today we'll explore an artist with a voice and a guitar sound unlike anyone else. She had the poet's words, and as you'll hear, she also had a painter's eye.
[00:00:53] Dave Anthony: Joni Mitchell brought all four of these elements together to change the possibilities of popular music. [00:01:00] From her famous song Both Sides Now to the emotional depths of her critically acclaimed album Blue, she pioneered a place for women in songwriting and performing, inspired generations, won Grammys, and pushed beyond folk and pop into other adventurous forms of music.
[00:01:18] Dave Anthony: You'll also experience the life of upheaval behind that extraordinary music: a childhood disease, a daughter placed for adoption, a further devastating health challenge. And here to discuss the restless talent, fierce independence, and extraordinary journey of Joni Mitchell is Allison Rapp, a New York City-based writer and assistant editor at Ultimate Classic Rock magazine.
[00:01:41] Dave Anthony: She's also the host of Big Yellow Podcast, a podcast dedicated to the life and works of Joni Mitchell. Welcome to Garage to Stadiums, Allison.
[00:01:51] Allison Rapp: Thank you so much for having me. It's a pleasure.
[00:01:53] Dave Anthony: Tell us a little bit about the Big Yellow
[00:01:55] Allison Rapp: Podcast. I thought there's lots of podcasts about Bob Dylan and The Beatles and [00:02:00] plenty of other artists, and Joni always struck me as somebody who deserved that kind of attention, research, and platform as well.
[00:02:07] Allison Rapp: And then I had the opportunity to actually go out to see Joni Mitchell perform at that show in Washington State at the Gorge Amphitheatre. It just blew my mind, blew everything about what I knew about Joni, and decided, yeah, now is the time. We need to be talking about this artist now while she's still around, and we can have these conversations as she's still a living, breathing artist.
[00:02:28] Dave Anthony: We're gonna flip back to Joni's childhood, and she was born Roberta Joan Anderson in Fort Macleod, Alberta, which is about an hour and a half from the Canadian city of Calgary and an hour north of the US border. Tell us about Joni's childhood, where she was born, grew up, and some notable things about her family life.
[00:02:46] Allison Rapp: At the time, her mother was a teacher, and her father was a pilot instructor. He worked for the Royal Canadian Air Force at the time. But they weren't there for all that long. They ultimately end up making their way to Saskatoon, [00:03:00] Saskatchewan, which is where kind of Joni considers herself to be from. She was an only child, so I think that is something that's important to remember about her childhood is she didn't necessarily have the kind of sibling relationship certainly that some art- other artists of her era did.
[00:03:14] Allison Rapp: But for all accounts, she was a pretty Social butterfly in school. She was well liked, had a good number of friends. She worked for the school newspaper. She worked in town for a local clothing designer selling clothes. Hmm. She would attend the regular local school dances. She was really into dancing as a kid.
[00:03:33] Allison Rapp: So she was certainly a social kid despite being an only child. And as, as I'm sure a lot of listeners here know, it's a pretty rural part of the country. There's not necessarily a lot- Yeah ... going on around it. Probably most important thing to remember about Joni's childhood is that when she was nine she contracted polio, and that took up kind of a huge chunk of, of her childhood.
[00:03:54] Allison Rapp: Obviously it, it was a pretty traumatic experience physically for her. Um, but [00:04:00] she, you know, later then relayed stories about being in the hospital around Christmastime when she was a kid recovering from this disease and singing Christmas carols to the other kids in the hospital ward, and kind of that being her first experience of singing for other people, having an audience, and having your voice be reacted to by other people.
[00:04:20] Allison Rapp: I would go so far as to say that that experience when she was a child really was a big shaping factor in who she ultimately became.
[00:04:27] Dave Anthony: She continues on with music, has a foray into the music scene in Calgary playing in coffee houses, and attends art school. And I think that not everybody knows that about Joni, is the art school phase.
[00:04:41] Allison Rapp: Yeah. It's funny, music was not necessarily Joni's first choice. It was not necessarily the, the ultimate end goal. Visual art was her primary medium. For a time, actually, she wanted to work in, in the fashion industry. I mentioned that she really loved to dance. She thought maybe she would be a dancer. Hmm.
[00:04:57] Allison Rapp: Music was not the first option. She went to art school, [00:05:00] and she has consistently ever since then told, considers herself a, a visual artist first who just happens to write songs.
[00:05:07] Dave Anthony: So that would've been the early '60s she starts going to- Right ... art college. And something happens that's pretty significant during that period.
[00:05:15] Allison Rapp: Yeah. So Joni ends up getting pregnant, and she's very young of course and doesn't necessarily have supportive system behind her. She's left home. She's an only child. She doesn't have a lot of family. Um, and of course, in those years, as, as we know, getting pregnant at that age without those resources was just a huge deal.
[00:05:35] Allison Rapp: She was an art student. She didn't have a lot of money. There weren't a lot of options for somebody like that in those days. And talk about just a really daunting scenario to find yourself in. And she ends up heading down to Toronto while she's still pregnant and finding an apartment there where there were some other single, unwed mothers in the same neighborhood.
[00:05:56] Allison Rapp: Joni has to make choices about how she ultimately wants to proceed. She [00:06:00] does decide that she wants to have this baby. And she's- For all intents and purposes, a- a- alone. And that's a terrifying situation for anyone, but I think especially for somebody who is on the cusp of just figuring out what they wanna do with their artistic career.
[00:06:13] Dave Anthony: She's trying to play the coffee house circuit in a neighborhood of Toronto called Yorkville, which was an arts and culture neighborhood where the folk scene started to take off. Would she have had her own compositions at that time, or would she still be playing the folk standards of the day?
[00:06:29] Allison Rapp: She was mainly performing the folk standards, but this is a period where she starts dabbing her toe more into her own songwriting.
[00:06:36] Allison Rapp: And the first song that she can remember kind of writing both the music and the lyrics for is something called Day After Day
[00:06:44] Joni Mitchell: Day after day, miles and miles
[00:06:52] Joni Mitchell: Night after night
[00:06:55] Allison Rapp: Which she wrote on the train to Toronto, um, is the story that she tells. I do think it's [00:07:00] important to remember that at this time, people who were considering themselves folk singer-songwriters, um, actually weren't calling themselves songwriters at that point. Most people were playing the folk standards.
[00:07:09] Allison Rapp: Bob Dylan was doing that. Leonard Cohen was doing... Lots of people were doing that at that time. That transition hadn't really happened fully yet.
[00:07:17] Dave Anthony: Next, Joni faces an impossible situation. With no money, struggling as a musician in Toronto, and a small baby to take care of, she's forced to make the most challenging decision of her young life.
[00:07:31] Announcer: Garage to stadiums, the performers we cover come from all over the world, and so do our listeners. We have listeners in over 100 countries. Join us from wherever you are
[00:07:44] Promo : I'm Alan Kozin, a former music reviewer for The New York Times and co-author with Adrian Sinclair of The McCartney Legacy, a multi-volume biography of Paul McCartney focusing on his career after The Beatles.
[00:07:57] Promo : You're listening to the Garage to [00:08:00] Stadiums Music History podcast, telling the stories of our music legends.
[00:08:08] Dave Anthony: She marries an American folk singer named Chuck Mitchell that she meets on the folk circuit. It lasted only a year and a half. She marries him in '65. Yeah. And looking back, why do you think she married him?
[00:08:20] Allison Rapp: I think there's a couple of factors that go into this. One, of course, being that Chuck Mitchell by that time was a relatively established person in the folk scene and could open a few doors for Joni in that sense-
[00:08:31] Dave Anthony: Mm-hmm
[00:08:31] Allison Rapp: speaking professionally. But also, she has her baby in February of 1965, and she and Chuck get married in June of 1965. And at that point, Joni is still of the mindset that she, that she can make this work and figure out a way to build this family and- Joni's story, and I say that specifically because Chuck's version of the story is perhaps a little bit different.
[00:08:55] Allison Rapp: Joni's version is that Chuck told her, "Yes, I will do this with you. I will help you [00:09:00] raise this child. This will be our life. I'm willing to do this with you." But Joni has said that the second she walked down the aisle she realized that wasn't ultimately gonna be the case, that that was not gonna be the family that they ultimately created.
[00:09:11] Allison Rapp: Mm. That was certainly a, a, a complicated situation for her. Ultimately, she gives her baby daughter up for adoption, but I think she made choices at the time thinking not just of herself, but of her child then.
[00:09:22] Dave Anthony: I mean, the '64 to '66 period is that Toronto period, and the baby, and the marriage. Yeah. And then in '67 her music gets discovered by others.
[00:09:31] Dave Anthony: She's starting to write her own compositions. How did her songs get discovered by people like Buffy Sainte-Marie, who did The Circle Game? Judy Collins- Yeah ... Both Sides Now. Country singer George Hamilton IV, Urge For Going.
[00:09:46] Allison Rapp: Joni ultimately makes her way to New York City, where at the time there's a really big folk movement happening.
[00:09:52] Allison Rapp: That's where Bob Dylan is, and that's where, as you mentioned, Judy Collins and Buffy Sainte-Marie, and this whole gaggle just of folk people is hanging out in [00:10:00] Greenwich Village. And Joni makes her way there. Everybody's playing the same venues. People are going to one another's apartments and playing their music.
[00:10:07] Allison Rapp: I was fortunate enough to have Judy Collins on my podcast and talk about this a little bit more. Yep. She was already established then. She gets a call in the middle of the night from a guy called Al Kooper, who you might recognize as having worked with Bob Dylan. He says, "You've gotta hear this girl. I just met this girl.
[00:10:21] Allison Rapp: You've gotta hear this." And he puts Joni on the phone and she plays Both Sides Now over the phone to Judy Collins, and Judy Collins is blown away. And she's like, "That's the most beautiful song I've ever heard. I have to record that." And she does, of course. So, you know, it really was a matter of kind of so-and-so telling so-and-so, like, "Oh, you've gotta meet so-and-so."
[00:10:41] Allison Rapp: Um, and, and that's how people like Judy Collins and Leonard Cohen and all these other people are, are, you know, meeting her.
[00:10:47] Dave Anthony: Right. She was such a pioneer that others cite as an influence. But looking back, who would you say influenced her music in the early days of her songwriting?
[00:10:56] Allison Rapp: Joni's talked about hearing some of those earlier Bob Dylan records and [00:11:00] having something of an epiphany where she goes, "Oh, I, I heard Bob Dylan's Positively 4th Street and realized you can write about anything."
[00:11:08] Allison Rapp: Mm. You don't necessarily have to fit these lyrics into particular boxes. You don't necessarily have to work in particular verse, refrain, chorus structure. The, the world is our oyster here. She has talked about- Being an average kid in those days in the sense that she was really into Chuck Berry and Elvis Presley and was dancing to a lot of those records at her school dances and found that music to be really electrifying to her.
[00:11:32] Allison Rapp: She also has talked about listening to people like Duke Ellington and things like that- Right ... at the time, and starting to pick up some of those seeds that'll end up coming out a little bit later in her music in, say, the '70s. I, I think she's really pulling from very different worlds here in that sense.
[00:11:50] Dave Anthony: Which leads us to her first album, Song to a Seagull.[00:12:00]
[00:12:00] Joni Mitchell: Rid me off to his country for marriage too soon.
[00:12:07] Dave Anthony: David Crosby offers to be her producer on it. It was modestly received. It had many sound mix challenges based on Crosby trying to produce it. What's interesting about this album is it doesn't have some of her early compositions that others did. Was that deliberate?
[00:12:23] Allison Rapp: I think it's a confluence of a couple of things. I think one, again, a lot of folk singers at this time were not putting their originals on their first album. I mean, Bob Dylan- Yeah ... wasn't doing that either. Joni wasn't necessarily as just confident in those songs quite yet. Even in spite of these people telling her how good they were and having this encouragement, I just don't think she was fully there yet.
[00:12:43] Allison Rapp: And then on top of that too, I don't think that anybody is all that confident when they're in their studio for the first time, having never made a professional record before. So Joni had not become the, the boss in the studio in the way that she ultimately would [00:13:00] become.
[00:13:00] Dave Anthony: Joni Mitchell incredibly played a role in the formation of Crosby, Stills, and Nash.
[00:13:05] Dave Anthony: Here's the story. In 1968, Graham Nash flew from London to visit his new love, Joni, and he remembers finding David Crosby and Stephen Stills at her house singing a Stephen Stills song, You Don't Have To Cry. Nash added his harmony, the voices locked together.
[00:13:29] Dave Anthony: Here in Joni's living room, Crosby, Stills, and Nash had found their sound, and Joni had helped set the stage for the birth of one of rock's greatest super groups. For Joni's second album, Clouds, Reprise Records brought in Paul Rothchild, the producer who had helped shape The Doors' explosive sound and helped guide them from a Venice Beach garage to international superstardom.
[00:13:52] Dave Anthony: Dug our treasures
[00:13:54] Song : there[00:14:00]
[00:14:04] Dave Anthony: Rothschild pursued his musical vision relentlessly. With The Doors, he demanded take after take, painstakingly refining performances, and even banning guitarist Robby Krieger from using a wah-wah pedal. He had firm ideas about how an artist should sound and the success to back them up. But with Joni, that determination met its match.
[00:14:26] Dave Anthony: When her swaying interfered with his microphone sound, he actually taped her feet to the studio floor. For her, it drained the joy for making music. When Rothschild left for two weeks to work with The Doors, Joni seized her chance. With engineer Henry Lewy, she finished the album herself. For a young woman still establishing herself, taking control from such an accomplished producer was a bold move, and it foreshadowed the fierce independence from that day forward.
[00:14:55] Dave Anthony: The second album has Chelsea Morning. [00:15:00]
[00:15:01] Joni Mitchell: Woke up, it was a Chelsea morning, and the first thing that I heard was a song outside my window, and the traffic wrote the words. It
[00:15:11] Dave Anthony: came- Both sides now, Joni performing those Rows
[00:15:16] Joni Mitchell: and flows of angel hair and ice cream castles in the air
[00:15:27] Dave Anthony: What is it, in your opinion, Annette, was different about this album that drew so much attention? Because it did win a Grammy.
[00:15:32] Allison Rapp: Yeah, it did. I do think that if you listen to both of those albums back to back, you can tell that Joni is feeling better about her own songwriting in terms of her understanding what kind of conversations to have in a studio if you're co-producing a record with somebody, as she was in this case.
[00:15:48] Dave Anthony: Mm-hmm. In August 1969, Woodstock brought together Jimi Hendrix, Janis Joplin, The Who, The Band, Jefferson Airplane, Creedence Clearwater Revival, and nearly half a million young people. [00:16:00] Joni Mitchell had been scheduled to perform, but David Geffen feared the chaos and gridlocked roads would prevent her from returning to New York for The Dick Cavett Show, a crucial television appearance early in her career.
[00:16:15] Dave Anthony: So Joni watched Woodstock unfold from a hotel room, absorbing the television images, and later hearing firsthand accounts from her boyfriend, Graham Nash, whose group Crosby, Stills, Nash & Young played only its second-ever public performance there. From that distance, Joni captured what Woodstock meant, not merely what happened.
[00:16:37] Dave Anthony: The result was its defining anthem, fittingly titled Woodstock, which became a hit for her boyfriend Graham Nash's group, CSNY, on their 1970 album Deja Vu.
[00:16:52] CSNY: We are stardust. We are golden. We are billion[00:17:00]
[00:17:04] Dave Anthony: The seven- 1970 album, Ladies of the Canyon, had some of her big hits, uh, Big Yellow Taxi
[00:17:13] Joni Mitchell: They seem to go that you don't know what you've got till it's gone. The day paradise put up a parking lot.
[00:17:24] Dave Anthony: The Woodstock song Circle Game.
[00:17:26] Joni Mitchell: And tear fall at the-
[00:17:35] Joni Mitchell: The seasons they go round
[00:17:40] Dave Anthony: After Ladies of the Canyon, Joni Mitchell did something few rising stars would dare to do. She stepped away. She left Laurel Canyon, crossed the Atlantic, and disappeared into a freer, more anonymous life, eventually settling among the cave-dwelling travelers of Matala, Crete in Greece, [00:18:00] in the Greek islands.
[00:18:01] Dave Anthony: Why, why does she briefly retire, do you think, after this album? She kinda goes on a hiatus. What do you think drove that?
[00:18:09] Allison Rapp: Well, as you said, the second album did really well. It earned her a ton of attention in what we would consider, you know, a, a pretty short amount of time, and I just don't think that Joni, particularly for her personality at the time, was really ready for that, or at least really ready for the kind of onslaught of attention that was going to bring.
[00:18:28] Allison Rapp: We're talking about somebody who is still very young still at this point, still wrestling, I think, quite a bit with what she wants to be and how she wants to be it. At this point, nobody knew that she'd given up the baby for adoption, certainly, and I think she was still struggling to figure out what that path forward was going to look like, and this onslaught of fame wasn't helpful.
[00:18:49] Dave Anthony: Next, could Joni possibly make a comeback to the heights she had already experienced and walked away from?
[00:18:58] Announcer: How do we give you the real stories of [00:19:00] music history? Because we talk to the insiders, rock journalists, authors, and filmmakers who live and breathe music.
[00:19:07] Announcer: Do you love Garage to Stadiums? We'd appreciate if you left a review on your favorite podcast platform.
[00:19:14] Dave Anthony: The respite that Joni took affected her in several profound ways. Each new experience, relationship, and moment of reflection eventually finding its way into a deeply personal song. One song was the song Kerry. While away she found love. In Matala, she met Kerry Raditz, a red-haired American working as a cook at the Mermaid Cafe.
[00:19:36] Dave Anthony: They formed a brief relationship, shared a cave, and traveled through Greece together, and Joni began writing the song Kerry for his 24th birthday, capturing the joy of their temporary freedom.
[00:19:48] Joni Mitchell: And I miss my clean white linen and my fancy French clothes[00:20:00]
[00:20:02] Dave Anthony: Well, the second way that the respite paid off was she began experimenting with new instruments. On a newly acquired Appalachian instrument called the dulcimer that she bought from an instrument maker for $200 at the Big Sur Music Festival before she left, she created All I Want, a song that discussed searching for emotional clarity beyond fame
[00:20:38] Dave Anthony: The third way that break paid off was she found the balance between travel and loneliness, and the song California balanced that thrill of travel against loneliness and homesickness.
[00:20:52] Joni Mitchell: All the California[00:21:00]
[00:21:00] Joni Mitchell: I'm gonna see the folks I dig. I'll even kiss a sunset pig
[00:21:05] Dave Anthony: And the fourth way was in that period of deep reflection, she was able to confront her past, and she returned to write Little Green, confronting the adoption that forced her to surrender her daughter in 1965.
[00:21:30] Joni Mitchell: Choose her a name she will answer to
[00:21:36] Dave Anthony: The hiatus gave Joni distance. Distance gave her perspective, and that perspective leads us to June '71, which is the famous- Mm ... album Blue. It had Carey- Mm ... the song California, This Flight Tonight, an amazing song called River.
[00:21:53] Joni Mitchell: Don't snow here. It stays pretty green. I'm gonna make a lot of money.
[00:21:59] Joni Mitchell: Then I'm gonna quit [00:22:00] this crazy scene. I wish I had a river I could skate
[00:22:06] Dave Anthony: away. And a Case of You. What's your view of this album? Is this the career masterpiece?
[00:22:10] Allison Rapp: When Blue came out, it was not thought of in those terms whatsoever. It's thought of in those terms now. It's been through kind of the retrospective conversations of the last 30, 40 years.
[00:22:22] Allison Rapp: But at the time that it was released, it was really not like anything else that was out there. It was considered far too vulnerable, just emotionally intense. There's a famous story of Kris Kristofferson hanging out with her not that long after Blue comes out, and, and he says to her, "Geez, Joni, will you save something of yourself?"
[00:22:39] Allison Rapp: Just this kind of implication that she almost gave away too much of what she was feeling- Wow ... on that record. Huh. I know that Bob Dylan heard that record and had a full circle moment and realized, "Joni is saying things that I would never dare say on a record." So I think in many ways, it was inspiring to people at the time.
[00:22:57] Allison Rapp: It was also terrifying to people at the time- [00:23:00] Hmm ... because they thought, "Do we have to write like this now? Is this the benchmark for what we have to do?" So yeah, I think it was a complicated kind of release at the time, but it's been through a lot of looking backward that we've realized how powerful of an album it really is.
[00:23:13] Dave Anthony: It's interesting because that has been named in the top three albums of all time by Rolling Stone Magazine. This is- Mm ... an interesting point you're making, that she was almost extra vulnerable relative to others.
[00:23:24] Allison Rapp: It was that combination of Joni saying certain things, using certain words that other artists weren't necessarily willing to do, but also her arrangements of her songs, the instrumentation that she was choosing to use, the kind of sparseness of it.
[00:23:39] Allison Rapp: You feel a bit like you're in the room with her, in the studio just watching this unfold. It feels so personal that way, in a, in, in a way that I don't know that those other records really did for people at the time.
[00:23:51] Dave Anthony: She was dating James Taylor during this period, and, and I'll dare to ask this question.
[00:23:55] Dave Anthony: Do you think Taylor had any influence, or vice versa? Did she in turn have any influence on his [00:24:00] music?
[00:24:00] Allison Rapp: Yeah. The short answer to that is yes, of course. He plays on a couple of tracks on Blue, and Joni ends up singing some backing vocals on James Taylor's songs. I think that the most important part of that situation was that, you know, James Taylor was really struggling heavily with his drug addiction at that point, and that was the first time, I think, that Joni realizing that there was very little that she could do herself to help.
[00:24:22] Allison Rapp: Um, and I think that affected her emotionally a great deal, and it, it spilled into the songs that she was writing.
[00:24:28] Dave Anthony: Mm-hmm. She has her first Top 40 hit in '72 off the For the Roses album, Turn Me On, I'm a Radio.
[00:24:35] Joni Mitchell: Oh honey, you-
[00:24:49] Dave Anthony: Next, Joni's physical limitation caused by her childhood bout with polio begin to affect her music. How can she possibly overcome this limitation? [00:25:00]
[00:25:02] Announcer: Garage to Stadiums Music History podcast, now in the top 3% of podcasts globally. Wanna go deeper? Head to Garage to Stadiums online for more from this story
[00:25:17] Dave Anthony: As we discussed, polio had weakened Joni's left hand, what affected her ability to play traditional chords. We discussed how Joni was also a painter, and she approached music the same way, mixing new colors to create her own musical palette. Here's how. Incredibly, she experimented with tunings, changing the notes of the strings.
[00:25:38] Dave Anthony: This allowed her to reach sounds her fingers otherwise could not. Joni even came up with a numbering system that allowed other musicians to follow her lead. Like, the- Yeah ... the woman's a, the genius.
[00:25:50] Allison Rapp: It's so crazy. When you pick up a guitar and you try to play a Joni Mitchell song, it's gonna take you a minute to figure it out, 'cause she's never playing in a regular standard tuning, and she's, um, [00:26:00] famous now for using these open tunings on guitars and using these really bizarre chord structures.
[00:26:05] Allison Rapp: Polio ended up weakening the muscles in her hands, and so she had to figure out new ways of playing the guitar that obviously weren't traditional at the time in order for her hands to be able to do that.
[00:26:16] Dave Anthony: However, some pop session players struggled because her strange new chords didn't follow the usual musical roadmap.
[00:26:23] Dave Anthony: Jazz musicians were accustomed to complex harmonies and improvisation. They didn't need every chord explained. They could listen, interpret, and respond, and helped bring Joni's extraordinary imaginations to life, sparking her entry into the jazz world. Their sophistication would allow her to execute some of this vision that she had where she felt that pop musicians weren't quite getting it.
[00:26:47] Dave Anthony: It's so interesting.
[00:26:49] Allison Rapp: It, it is kind of fascinating, and I think to a large degree, it's fortunate that the people that Joni worked with in those days were as open-minded and, and willing to experiment as, as [00:27:00] she was then.
[00:27:01] Dave Anthony: And 1974's Court and Spark had more of jazz feeling to it, and featured some sophisticated songs like Help Me
[00:27:23] Dave Anthony: Free Man in Paris?
[00:27:26] Speaker 6: I was a free man in Paris
[00:27:37] Dave Anthony: "Raised on Robbery." This album peaked at number two on the US charts. She had experimented with Tom Scott on woodwinds, flutes on her previous album, but now she brought Tom Scott's full band into the studio. They were known as the LA Express and had sophisticated jazz stylings in their songs. And the title of the album, Court and Spark, came from her [00:28:00] burgeoning relationship with the jazz drummer in the group named John Guerin.
[00:28:03] Song : 1975,
[00:28:05] Dave Anthony: The Hissing of Summer Lawns, which took the accessible jazz pop fusion of Court and Spark and pushed it in a much more experimental, challenging direction.
[00:28:14] Joni Mitchell: Sweet amour, mama Not cheap display And we were
[00:28:29] Dave Anthony: After the chart success with Court and Spark album, this album didn't get great reviews. Do you think in retrospect it's a fair appraisal?
[00:28:38] Allison Rapp: Yes and no. Hejira for me specifically has always been an album that took me several listens certainly to get into the meat and potatoes of it and start to absorb it.
[00:28:47] Allison Rapp: It's not something you can listen to once and understand or even appreciate. There really is a big leap between Court and Spark and Hejira. We're not necessarily talking about a subtle shift in direction here. But I also do think there are [00:29:00] kind of more accessible moments in that album than I think people give it credit for.
[00:29:06] Allison Rapp: Certainly thematically it touches on a lot of ideas of fame and notoriety and careers, and how personal relationships play into all of those things. It's a bit more accessible now maybe than it, it was at the time, at least to fans who were expecting one thing and got something-
[00:29:21] Dave Anthony: It's interesting, other artists have gone that route.
[00:29:24] Dave Anthony: We did an episode on Carlos Santana. Mm. Santana went down that jazzy route in the '70s. Yeah. And the guest that we had on, Ashley Kahn, said, "In some ways these people are so talented, Carlos, Joni, and others, that they are looking for a challenge. They wanna keep pushing the envelope of sound, their stylings, et cetera."
[00:29:46] Dave Anthony: And it sounds like this, along with some of the things you talked about earlier, the polio changed the way she did chord structures. The ability to- Yeah ... execute that couldn't be done by the pop guys. It had to move to jazz. There's a confluence of things here that [00:30:00] drove it.
[00:30:01] Allison Rapp: Yeah, that and I think some people are in her ear trying to talk her into moving one direction, and Joni's always been the sort of person that if you try to do that, she will go the opposite way.
[00:30:12] Allison Rapp: There's that element of it, too, the, of her really wanting to prove that she was going to stay true to her art no matter what.
[00:30:21] Dave Anthony: By 1976, with her romance with drummer John Guerin unraveling, she hit the highway seeking distance from the turmoil, and those journeys helped shape the next album, the 1976 album Hejira, released in November.
[00:30:35] Dave Anthony: It sounded pushed further into jazz with conversational melodies. She called it Hejira because it captured the idea of leaving her old life behind. Joni found the word in a dictionary. It comes from the Arabic word hijrah, associated with Muhammad's migration from Mecca to Medina in the year 622. She interpreted it personally as running [00:31:00] away honorably, quote, unquote, leaving a relationship without treating the breakup as anyone's failure.
[00:31:06] Dave Anthony: That fit her separation from John Guerin and the journeys that inspired the album In 1976, the album went to number 13 on the charts and featured the song Coyote. She's actually painted or drawn the album covers in some cases, which I don't think a lot of people know. Yeah. She briefly studied painting illustration, as we talked about, at art college.
[00:31:26] Dave Anthony: She considers herself a painter first, as you said. How do you think being a painter influenced her song compositions?
[00:31:33] Allison Rapp: I think for Joni, it really comes out in the form of really being able to see the structure of a song sort of like you would a painting, and thinking about different session players as being different colors on different paintbrushes, and being able to think, "I want this part of the painting to look like this, so I'm going to hire such and such person."
[00:31:54] Allison Rapp: There are accounts of her kind of being in the studio and saying some really weird things to session players, like, [00:32:00] "I want this section to sound like orange," or, "I want this section to sound like a beach trip." Just the really abstract ideas that she can visualize really easily in her head as this kind of visual artist, as a painter, took some session players a minute to get used to understanding in the studio.
[00:32:18] Dave Anthony: Right. The albums didn't do as well, obviously, as some of the earlier ones, these kind of jazzier things. Do you think she lost her core audience that loved the earlier songs that had the singer-songwriter stylings and the poetry of the early days?
[00:32:32] Allison Rapp: It's hard to say, 'cause I'm not ever sure exactly who Joni's core audience was at the time.
[00:32:38] Allison Rapp: I think that core audience was always shifting i- in some ways, and there were a lot of people who, quote-unquote, "got Joni" in certain eras and then didn't get Joni and then re-got her later on in other albums. People have moved in and out of that circle. But yeah, there were certainly people who really loved Court and Spark and saw an incredible thing happening there that I think they [00:33:00] hoped was just going to be a follow-up in a similar vein.
[00:33:04] Allison Rapp: Again, I think a large part of that goes back to Joni just not wanting to move with the grain, critically, commercially, no matter what, and losing fans at that point, that didn't make a difference to her.
[00:33:17] Dave Anthony: Joni passed through the 1980s with a variety of sounds, including pop and synthesizer elements. In 1982, she even hired Thomas Dolby, the singer behind Blinded Me With Science, to produce a synthesizer-driven album that did not perform well.
[00:33:32] Dave Anthony: However, once the '90s rolled around, Joni came back in 1991 with a single, Come In From The Cold.
[00:33:47] Joni Mitchell: Just a-coming for
[00:33:53] Dave Anthony: And in 1994 with an album called Turbulent Indigo, which won Grammy for Best Pop Album. And [00:34:00] then in the year 2000, she did a jazz album featuring covers of jazz standards like At Last by Etta James, and even a great memorable jazz version of her hit Both Sides Now.
[00:34:27] Dave Anthony: Which was particularly poignant with now older and experienced Joni singing the song and lending it a new perspective from the young 20-something woman Joni was when she wrote it. You've talked a little bit about her personality. How would you describe Joni if you sort of had to draw a composite of her for everyone who didn't really know the woman?
[00:34:47] Allison Rapp: That's a great question. She's not everybody's cup of tea, and she has pissed off a lot of people along the way certainly. She can be very blunt. She will tell you her opinion certainly, if you're [00:35:00] asking for it, and probably then some. I think that a lot of that has to do with the fact that she had to figure stuff out on her own.
[00:35:09] Allison Rapp: Having polio as a child, being an unwed mother and having a baby at a very young age, developing a full career on her own, and not having either a template or a strong kind of support system to do that with, that does breed the sort of personality that you need to have in that scenarios. So yeah, Joni could be really brash.
[00:35:29] Allison Rapp: There are stories too that I've heard where she's been mean to waitstaff and, like, she's just the kind of person that you have to watch your back around a little bit. And I have to say that I respect that kind of a great deal in terms of the era that she was coming up in and how-
[00:35:45] Dave Anthony: That's interesting you talk about that era, because we had Mark Blake, who's a rock journalist, wrote about Fleetwood Mac, and he said, "I don't think people appreciate what Stevie Nicks and Christine McVie had to go through, being women in rock."
[00:35:58] Dave Anthony: Like, these [00:36:00] sexist musicians around them, or people who were roadies or whatever. He talked about this. He said they had to be extra tough, and they had to really survive. That would've been a different era for women in music.
[00:36:12] Allison Rapp: Without a doubt. I think in many ways Joni realized the game she was up against and decided to just play the game harder.
[00:36:19] Allison Rapp: There, there's a quote too. Bob Dylan was asked about her at one point, I think it was maybe mid-'70s, and he, his quote was, "Joni is sort of like a man." And, like, that, that kind of sums up a good deal of how other people were sort of viewing her at that point. It is a reductive quote, but it points to the idea that Joni was really aware of that at the time and wasn't going to let it hinder anything.
[00:36:44] Dave Anthony: Next, a surprise person returns to Joni's life. How would the reunion go?
[00:36:53] Announcer: Do you have playlists for all the bands that matter? Well, we do, and you can download them for free by visiting the bonus [00:37:00] content section of our website for a link to each performer's curated playlist. If you like Tom Petty, Stevie Nicks, the Eagles, or Elton John, check out our full episode list now streaming on all podcast platforms.
[00:37:13] Dave Anthony: Moving forward in the '90s, something incredible happens.
[00:37:17] Allison Rapp: When Joni gave birth, she named her daught- daughter Kelly Dale Anderson. That was her given name at the time, and she was adopted at a very young age as an infant by a Canadian family and raised under the name Killoran. That was her name. Mm-hmm. And eventually, Killoran reaches a stage in her life where she becomes a little bit more curious about who her birth parents are, and the only information that she had at the time was that her mother's occupation, a musician.
[00:37:42] Allison Rapp: And she started having conversations with friends and trying to pick together the timeline, like what year was I born, and who was around the Toronto area, and that, and figuring out ultimately that Joni Mitchell was her mother. And by that time, Killoran had a son of her own, so there was Joni's grandson in the picture.
[00:37:58] Allison Rapp: The interviews that she gives at [00:38:00] the time are really heartwarming, and it's sweet, and there's a lot of love there clearly, but there's also, you know, years of kind of familial confusion and trauma to have unpacked there. It's been something of an up and down relationship between the two of them, but ultimately a good resolution for that.
[00:38:18] Dave Anthony: In 2015, a devastating brain aneurysm left Joni struggling to walk and speak. Years of rehabilitation followed as she rebuilt her life and relearned the guitar. Music slowly returned through gatherings with friends at home, and then in July 2022, she stunned the Newport Folk Festival, singing on stage again.
[00:38:41] Dave Anthony: The performance became a Grammy-winning live album, another extraordinary comeback powered by that same fierce determination. Who do you think she's influenced? When I listen to her catalog in preparation for the episode and the unique vocal stylings, one performer that came to mind was Sarah McLachlan.[00:39:00]
[00:39:15] Allison Rapp: Yeah. Oh, definitely. And Sarah McLachlan is somebody who has now played with Joni live on a couple of stages and has been a part of that kind of revival band, if you wanna call it that. It's funny, now I'm reaching a point where I'm having trouble seeing who Joni hasn't influenced in some way. Yeah. It's getting to that point.
[00:39:36] Allison Rapp: Because really, you could start working your way up through the history of music. You start with people like Annie Lennox. She's a big fan of hers, and then you work your way up through people like Sheryl Crow and Fiona Apple, and some of these really popular '90s acts. If we're talking more in the contemporary sphere, I think you've got people like Harry Styles, for example, who kind of fell in love with the Blue [00:40:00] era.
[00:40:00] Allison Rapp: There's a story of him wanting to learn how to play the dulcimer so badly that he figured out how to contact the woman who originally gave Joni her first dulcimer, and asking her to teach him how to play the instrument. There's also this generation now of female singer-songwriters who have really just carried this torch from Blue up until now.
[00:40:21] Allison Rapp: Olivia Rodrigo, Taylor Swift, all of these different people who, again, with kind of the aid of technology, have been able to look backward at those records and see something of themselves in those albums, because Joni was a young woman herself making those records, and then being able to take that inspiration into a modern-day studio atmosphere.
[00:40:42] Dave Anthony: When the history of music is told, what'll they say about Joni? What's her place in music history?
[00:40:47] Allison Rapp: Joni's gonna be an integral part of that conversation. She has proven that, I think, more than once. What she's ultimately going to stand for is the idea of authenticity in [00:41:00] your artwork. Yeah. Refusing to bend to the grain of anyone, critically, commercially, or otherwise.
[00:41:08] Allison Rapp: Not being afraid to throw your entire being, really, into the music that you're making, into the art that you're making, and allowing yourself to be vulnerable enough to, A, share those feelings with the world, and B, maybe make something that people don't like, and being okay with kind of the idea that not everything's gonna be a hit that way.
[00:41:32] Allison Rapp: So I think her willingness to stand apart from the crowd, stick to what you believe is true to your art, and be unafraid of failure is ultimately what she's gonna stand for.
[00:41:44] Dave Anthony: I like that answer. If we had to put you on the spot, three favorite Joni tracks. You wanna apply to this question.
[00:41:50] Allison Rapp: This isn't, this isn't fair.
[00:41:51] Allison Rapp: This is usually what I ask my podcast guests. So I'm like, "This... Wow, do I do this to people? This is terrible." Now you know
[00:41:56] Dave Anthony: how it feels. Now you know.
[00:41:58] Allison Rapp: This is terrible. [00:42:00] Um, okay, so I'm gonna have to say A Case of You, just because that was really the kernel of everything for
[00:42:06] Joni Mitchell: me.
[00:42:14] Joni Mitchell: Darling and I would still be on my feet. Oh, I would still be on
[00:42:20] Allison Rapp: my feet I wouldn't be here talking to you right now if it wasn't for A Case of You. And then I also have to say Coyote.
[00:42:30] Joni Mitchell: No regrets, Coyote. We just come from such different sets of circumstance. I'm up all night in the studios in Europe. Her li-
[00:42:42] Allison Rapp: Because I think that was a really kind of key song for me in terms of understanding her progression as an artist and also just her place, the very male-dominated world that she existed in. And then third, this is kind of cliche, but I'm gonna say Big Yellow [00:43:00] Taxi
[00:43:02] Joni Mitchell: They seem to go that you don't know what you've got till it's gone.
[00:43:06] Joni Mitchell: The day paradise put up a parking lot '
[00:43:12] Allison Rapp: Cause it's the namesake of my podcast, and- ... I really, it, for me, a lot of it goes back to that fun, poppy version of Joni that I just love to hear.
[00:43:24] Dave Anthony: Today, we've been talking to Allison Rapp. She runs the podcast, the Big Yellow Podcast, and she dives deep into Joni's world with a variety of guests.
[00:43:35] Dave Anthony: And Allison, we wanted to thank you today. You've shed a light on a very complex character, Joni Mitchell, how she overcame some incredible challenges, survived in a world that was a challenging one of the '60s and '70s for women in music, and ultimately achieved some incredible things and influenced so many.
[00:43:54] Dave Anthony: And so we wanted to thank you for coming on today.
[00:43:57] Allison Rapp: Thank you so much, Dave. [00:44:00]
[00:44:00] Dave Anthony: Some closing notes on Joni Mitchell. Canadian singer Neil Young and Canadian singer Joni Mitchell, despite only knowing each other casually, had an early Canadian encounter that produced legendary music. During their initial meeting in Winnipeg, Manitoba, Neil played Joni his unreleased song Sugar Mountain, a bittersweet track about losing his youth, and stunned by the song, Joni in turn wrote her iconic hit, The Circle Game, as a direct response to comfort Neil about growing older.
[00:44:31] Dave Anthony: Robert Plant and Jimmy Page of Led Zeppelin were massive fans of Joni Mitchell. Both Plant and Page drew heavy inspiration from Joni when writing Going to California, specifically channeling the admiration for her and her music. Plant famously joked, "When you're in love with Joni Mitchell, you've really gotta write about it now and again."
[00:44:52] Dave Anthony: Plant introduced direct nods to Mitchell's work. The line "To find a queen without a king" references her song I Had a King from her [00:45:00] debut album. Plant even occasionally added the line "And she comes from Canada" during live performances. Here's an interesting detail about Joni Mitchell's romantic relationship with jazz drummer John Guerin.
[00:45:13] Dave Anthony: In 1972, on Joni's For the Roses, John Guerin played drums without even meeting Joni. Their musical collaboration became a romance during the next album, Court and Spark, which featured the hits Help Me and A Free Man in Paris. Joni Mitchell was an accomplished painter and illustrator, and her artwork includes Canadian prairie landscapes, portraits of fellow musicians like James Taylor, David Crosby, and Graham Nash, and many self-portraits.
[00:45:43] Dave Anthony: Her paintings have been publicly exhibited, including a major retrospective titled Voices: Joni Mitchell. John Lennon criticized Joni Mitchell in late 1973 and '74, while both were recording in adjacent studios at A&M in Hollywood. [00:46:00] Lennon later dismissed Mitchell as a too-twee, an overly quaint, dainty, or affectation-prone.
[00:46:07] Dave Anthony: He also said she was over-educated after she played him a track of her then in progress album Court and Spark, and he criticized the music as a product of over-education. Mitchell later recounted these interactions and attributed Lennon's abrasive and dismissive comments to a class divide, specifically his insecurity stemming from his working class Liverpool upbringing versus her middle class background.
[00:46:30] Dave Anthony: Joni's first album was dedicated to her English teacher. Grade seven English teacher encouraged her in the fields of poetry and writing. So she later dedicated her first album, Song to a Seagull, to that teacher. Joni Mitchell produced or co-produced most of her own albums. Out of her 19 studio albums, there was only one that she did not produce or co-produce herself.
[00:46:56] Dave Anthony: Her famous quote, "Well, did Mozart [00:47:00] have a producer?" She said that in a 1998 interview. "You have to judge," she said, "what you're trying to get at yourself." Joni Mitchell sang secretly backstage at the famous The Last Waltz concert, which was The Band's final performance and made into a documentary. And if you've watched The Last Waltz, you know Neil Young at one point sang Helpless, but during it, a backing vocal can be heard, which is actually Mitchell singing from behind the curtain.
[00:47:28] Dave Anthony: It was done this way to prevent giving away Mitchell's presence to the audience before her performance slot. Joni Mitchell is quite the poker player. She would often frequent the Eagles singer Glenn Frey's house for rounds of poker. They were played every Monday night after Monday Night Football and were known to go on until the early hours of the morning.
[00:47:50] Dave Anthony: In 1974, Joni Mitchell had a hit song that terrified David Geffen. Free Man in Paris captured the Asylum Records [00:48:00] boss Geffen finally catching his breath an ocean away from the ringing phones and relentless demands of stars like the Eagles and Bob Dylan. But Geffen reportedly begged her to leave it off the album.
[00:48:10] Dave Anthony: He had not publicly come out as gay and feared listeners would read between the lines. Joni had captured his taste of freedom, but Geffen feared she had revealed too much. We want to thank our listeners for making us now one of the top 3% of podcasts in the world, and we're listened to in more than 100 countries.
[00:48:29] Dave Anthony: So join the Garage to Stadiums nation. Subscribe on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or YouTube, and follow us on Instagram, YouTube Shorts, and X for bite-sized music history that'll surprise you every time you scroll. Special thanks to our production crew, Scott Campbell, Chad Raymond, Amelia Mariang, and Nigel Campbell.
[00:48:49] Dave Anthony: I'm Dave Anthony. Thanks for listening. See you next time for another Garage to Stadium story.