The Stones' Sympathy for Darkness and how it influenced their sound

by Dave Anthony

Host, Garage to Stadiums podcast

• Download our official Rolling Stones playlist on Apple or Spotify

• Follow GTS on Apple or Spotify podcasts

• Follow GTS on our social channels

• Sign up for the Garage to Stadiums e-newsletter to get more bonus content

• Access this episode's transcript

  
  

Picture a sweet apple-cheeked teenager boy named Michael in a 1959 British sporting documentary (see video inset) on rock climbing safety. And consider that just three years years later, he would use the moniker "Mick" to front a rock band that would become legendary for its menacing image. Yet, that teen's

transformation mirrors the evolution of The Rolling Stones into the dark angels of rock.

Few bands carried as much darkness in their mythology as The Rolling Stones. While the Beatles embodied the “light” of the British Invasion, the Stones became its shadow. Their story is riddled with scandals, addictions, betrayals, deaths, and violent concerts. These weren’t mere backdrops—they seeped into their music, shaping the sinister tracks that defined their legend. The Stones turned chaos into art, their songs sounding as dangerous as the lives they lived.

In our two-part episode The Story of The Rolling Stones, guest Christopher Sandford, author of Rolling Stones: Sixty Years, joined host Dave Anthony to reveal the inside story of the band’s rise. With fame came trials and tragedies that would have sunk lesser mortals. This essay explores the many sources of darkness and how The Stones managed not only overcame them but how it may have influenced their sound.

The "bad boy" DNA was spawned by their original brand positioning: the "anti-Beatles"

From the start, menace was part of their identity. Manager Andrew Loog Oldham marketed them as the anti-Beatles, asking parents, “Would you let your daughter marry a Rolling Stone?” Image soon became reality. They even panicked parents further with their "Let's Spend the Night Together" lyrics which Ed Sullivan forced them to change for his family-friendly Sunday night TV show.

Their bad boy image would continue to evolve. By the mid-1960s, Jagger, Richards, and Jones were targeted by police drug raids, their persecution magnified in headlines. Songs reflected this alienation: “Paint It Black” captured despair with its Eastern-tinged drone, while “Mother’s Little Helper” turned suburban malaise into a bitter satire of pill dependency.

Deaths haunted the band

Brian Jones, the band’s founder, personified tragedy. A gifted multi-instrumentalist who gave the Stones their early flair, he spiraled into paranoia and drug abuse, drifting from the group he created. Weeks after being ousted in 1969, he drowned at 27.

Jones' death hung heavily as the band staged a massive Hyde Park tribute, then closed the decade with Altamont—a free concert marred by violence and the fatal stabbing of a fan by unruly Hell's Angels , shockingly appointed as concert "security.". As Sandford observed, Jones’s death and the chaos at Altamont didn’t just mark the end of the ’60s; they cemented the Stones as the band most willing to stare directly into the abyss.

The music of that late 60s era—the horror-filled, historical recounting of “Sympathy for the Devil,” the unapologetic violence of “Midnight Rambler,” and the hard scrabble narrator in "Jumpin' Jack Flash" and especially the darkness of “Gimme Shelter”—felt steeped in dread.

Inner band relationships contributed to the darkness

“Gimme Shelter” remains the quintessential Stones song forged in turmoil. Keith Richards conceived its ominous riff while storms battered London, thunder rattling the windows as he played, his mind burdened by Anita Pallenberg’s torrid sex scenes with bandmate Mick Jagger on the set of the film Performance. That atmosphere of betrayal and apocalypse infused the track. Its lyrics—war, rape, murder—echoed both global unrest and the band’s collapsing inner circle. Then came Merry Clayton’s shattering vocal, cracked with raw force on “Rape, murder, it’s just a shot away,” giving the song its spine-chilling power. More than a track, it became a soundtrack for disaster, forever tied to images of war, riots, and chaos.

Financial battles amped up the tension

Financial ruin also colored their music. In the early ’70s, they discovered manager Allen Klein had stolen millions and seized their catalog. Fleeing Britain’s crushing taxes, they regrouped in Richards’s villa basement in the south of France to record Exile on Main St. Far from glamorous, sessions were choked with heroin, humidity, and paranoia.

Guitars slipped out of tune, amps buzzed, and vocals blurred. Yet from this swamp of sound emerged a masterpiece: murky, suffocating, but defiantly alive. Tracks like “All Down the Line” carried the grit of survival with its out-of-tune opening guitar riff, mirroring a band trapped and hunted but refusing to collapse.

Drugs fuelled the madness

Addiction, especially Richards’s heroin use,

left a deep imprint. “Sway” bluntly confessed, “That demon life has got you in its sway.” Richards recalled writing riffs “half awake, half gone.” His anthem “Before They Make Me Run” chronicled dodging law and self-destruction, while Jagger channeled manic paranoia in “Shattered.” These weren’t abstract lyrics; they were dispatches from the edge.

Chaotic concerts contributed to the storm clouds

Their concerts, too, fueled their dark legend. Altamont became the archetype of rock chaos, but riots and clashes with police had long shadowed their shows.

That danger reinforced the volatility of songs like “Street Fighting Man,” banned by some radio stations for supposedly inciting unrest. Jagger’s lyrics, though, suggested resignation more than revolution: “What can a poor boy do / Except sing in a rock and roll band?” The Stones didn’t shrink from controversy; they absorbed it, letting the danger feed their image as a soundtrack to disorder.

Even softer songs had a menacing edge....

Even softer songs carried a cruel edge. “Angie” may be tender, but “Under My Thumb” and “The Last Time” expose domination and cynicism in relationships. Where most bands wrote of love as salvation, the Stones painted it as manipulation or ruin. These perspectives mirrored their own betrayals and destructive affairs, reinforcing their reputation as truth-tellers of love’s darker side. he deaths around them deepened the aura. Beyond Jones, the Stones lost collaborators, crew, and friends to overdoses and accidents.

Tracks like “Sister Morphine” and “Dead Flowers” didn’t glamorize drug culture; they delivered it with gallows humor and bleak honesty. They sang not as outsiders but as survivors, their authority rooted in lived experience. Few bands have been so defined by calamity yet so adept at turning it into enduring music. Survival itself became part of the darkness—the sense that no matter what, they’d stagger out of the wreckage with riffs intact.

The Stones survived and thrived in the surrounding chaos

In the end, the Stones’ darker music is inseparable from the tragedies that defined them. Financial ruin, the loss of Brian Jones, Altamont, addiction, and endless controversy weren’t distractions from their art but its crucible. They turned disaster into electricity, chaos into riffs, menace into lyrics. Half a century later, their music still sounds dangerous—an eternal reminder that from darkness, the Rolling Stones forged fire. As Sandford framed it, their true genius was not just in writing great songs but surviving to evolve despite the dark challenges that continually seemed to confront them.